Review: The Missing (S2 E6/8), Wednesday 16th November, BBC1

WARNING: Embargoed for publication until 00:00:01 on 08/11/2016 - Programme Name: The Missing series 2 - TX: 16/11/2016 - Episode: n/a (No. 6) - Picture Shows:  Julien Baptiste (TCHEKY KARYO), Gemma Webster (KEELEY HAWES) - (C) New Pictures - Photographer: Steffan Hill
 (C) New Pictures – Photographer: Steffan Hill

Can we talk about the drill? I think we can. When army liaison officer Adam Gettrick was revealed to have been ‘Alice Webster”s captor and father to her child (or at least that’s what was inferred) and mercilessly and brutally killed German Polizei Jorn Lenhart with a cordless drill (I still can’t drive past a B&Q after that), everything changed. It was bold by Harry and Jack Williams to reveal the captor and/or killer so early, eschewing the usual last-episode reveal, but now we want answers. What happened between Gettrick and Alice Webster? Was the Alice Webster we saw in the Swiss restaurant and the cabin the Alice Webster? Where is Sophie Giroux? Where is Lena Garber? What did happen in Iraq and what did Stone, Reid and A N Other do? We might not have got all the answers tonight, but we got some, in another very strong episode.

NB: spoilers, la la la la la, spoilers, la la la

Once again this episode had a lot going on, but with the dual-timeline narrative having now chilled out a bit, we are getting some good characterisation. There’s just more time to do it. I’ve mentioned before that David Morrissey and Keeley Hawes (Sam and Gemma Webster) are two very fine actors that felt slightly in the background in the first half of the series, but in this episode they really showed their acting chops.

We saw them in both timelines struggling badly – in 2015 they were having supreme difficulty coming to terms with the loss of Alice, Gemma continually calling in sick to work, zoning out on the couch and  showing signs of depression; in 2016 Sam told her that Eve was pregnant with his child, and the pair was having difficulty in coming to terms with that news, too. In this present-day timeline Gemma, fully fuelled by the search for Alice, did something unexpected – she sat down with Eve and asked her if she was going to keep the baby. When she said no she almost urged her to keep it and not to get rid of it because of guilt. It’s alright to be selfish once in while, she told Eve. When Eve left the office briefly, she hooked into her computer and stole some records for Baptiste. Nice one Gemma.

Ah, Baptiste. The glue that holds this series together was really struggling. His condition had worsened and he was fully aware that his search needed to be stepped up a notch. Hallucinating didn’t help (we finally found out what the card he always carries with him was all about). He felt he was getting closer to the truth, tantalisingly close, but… he was also getting desperate. Frantic. Angry. Sometimes violent. In the final scene he confronted Nadia Herz (who had had quite the episode herself… she was released from hospital, found her incarcerated husband’s missing camera and saw pictures of Alice on there) after he had found that she had been with Stone and Reid in Iraq.

The most interest strand in tonight’s episode was Gettrick and Alice. We saw him clean up the mess after the drill incident, but we were also given some detail into his relationship with Alice. In the 2015 timeline he called what we know as Alice Webster ‘Alice’, which surely confirms that she is indeed Alice Webster. We saw how he locked Alice and their daughter in the room; we saw how, after he came home from work threw a conciliatory supermarket-bought sandwich to her for her meal; we saw him explain in a moment of exposition that his uncle had locked him up when he was a child; and, crucially, we saw Alice say that she wanted to live a normal life… together. This was Stockholm Syndrome off the charts – she loved her captor, and wanted to be with him… to exist as a ‘normal’ couple.

With all this back detail and extra (welcome) characterisation, this episode once again packed emotional punch (thanks mostly to the excellent Morrissey and Hawes), and creeped me out only the way kidnap stories can – through control, manipulation and incarceration somehow and sometimes comes love. What a world we live in.

Paul Hirons

For all our news and reviews on The Missing go here 


13 Comments Add yours

  1. Anne Percival says:

    But I am sure he called her Sophie, not Alice


    1. Colin C says:

      Yes he did call her Sophie in current day Switzerland – so maybe Alice really did die in the shed.


    2. Sara Latham says:

      Yes, ‘Alice’ is actually Sophie and the real Alice maybe the corpse in the shed…or not. Presumably Sophie and her captor staged all of this so that everyone thinks Sophie (as ‘Alice’) is dead and they can live in the cabin happily ever after!!


    3. I think it is Sophie who came back, didn’t perish in the fire, and that Alice is indeed dead and it was her DNA found in the shed. Gettrick had kidnapped both girls (possibly with AN Other), and during their incarceration Alice died – killed maybe by Sophie – by accident or design. Hence Sophie’s Stockholm Syndrome as she thought (or was more likely told) she would be blamed for everything.

      It’s been like a less funny Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt – without the captor being as good-looking as Jon Hamm’s Reverend Richard Wayne Gary Wayne.

      I haven’t really connected with any of the characters except for the lovely Julien Baptiste and poor policeman Jorn. I think I’m more interested in the atrocity in Iraq and how that happened.

      The biggest mystery in this is how the British Army was able to investigate with seemingly only one fairly junior redcap around – can’t imagine why the German police let Eve take the lead; didn’t the abduction happen on German sovereign territory outside the base?


  2. James Ringland says:

    Love your site. But, he did call her Sophie and even got mad at her when she accidentally spoke in French.


    1. Paul Hirons says:

      Hmm, could’ve sworn he called her Alice. Will check again!


      1. Hi Paul, love your site and your reviews are fabulous. Yes, he did call her “Sophie”. Looking forward to the next episodes of The Missing, it’s a great series.


      2. Paul Hirons says:

        Thank you Jessie – great to hear, means a lot. Keep reading and commenting!


    2. Charlotte Carling says:

      Oh, I thought that was very deliberate of her. I think Sophie is playing a very long game of some sort where she wants to achieve a secure non-Sophie identity, a safe home in Switzerland (or elsewhere), her daughter by her side and also somehow Gettrick dead.


  3. MikeB says:

    No one seems to have noticed that Jorn Lenhart is missing (ie dead).


    1. Sara Latham says:

      Yes, it wasn’t very convincing when Gettrick texted (as him) – surely they will notice soon!


      1. Sara Latham says:

        BTW, just wanted to add that I read the reviews regularly and I really like this site :)


      2. Paul Hirons says:

        Great, thanks Sara… now let’s see how The Missing shakes out!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.