REVIEW: Shetland (S5 E1/6)

One of the best British crime drama shows, Shetland, made a welcome return tonight. I say ‘best British crime drama’ because it really is, and has lots of the ingredients that make up successful and engrossing crime shows: a lead character that’s likeable and watchable, a supporting cast that exhibits the same kinds of characteristics, gorgeous, sometimes otherworldly landscapes, and interesting crimes that often have their roots tangled with the local community.

These virtues were evident in this series opener. DI Jimmy Perez (Dougie Henshall) lamented the fact that he was living in an empty house with a humdrum life, when the phone rang – a severed hand had been found washed up on a nearby beach. Soon, the head appeared on another beach.

It was a grisly start to proceedings.

In the very first scene, we had seen a young African man standing, shivering, in the middle of a road, rolling green hills and mist enveloping him. He had been waiting for someone. He looked out of place, afraid, cold. He wasn’t dressed for the elements. What was this man in a grey suit doing in Shetland?

And so the scramble for clues, and the procedural journey, began. We saw Sandy pore over CCTV footage, we saw Jimmy and Tosh interview people at the locations he might have visited, and we eventually got a name: Daniel. We also got that cocaine had been found in the bag he had been carrying.

As ever with Shetland, some characters from the local community presented themselves as the investigation developed: a fisherman whose boat Daniel seemed to take a particular interest in; an unhelpful man who worked at a scrap metal business; a sneering hotel owner; ‘away day girls’ living in a caravan near to a new pipeline. And then there was also local industry: could the crime have been connected to local fishing scams?

All these questions and all these tangents are what give Shetland real flavour, but even with all of these elements, the procedural journey never gets diluted. Watching Jimmy – already furrowed of brow and deeply affected by the young man’s horrible death – go about his business, you can’t help but root for him and can’t help but become embroiled in the case as he does.

Things were further complicated when Daniel’s estranged mother turned up out of the blue. She explained to Jimmy that she hadn’t seen her son since he was a child, and that ever since then he had lived with his father in Nigeria. The mystery deepened: what on earth was he doing on Shetland?

Olivia, the mother, seemed to be extremely sensitive about her connection to her son, often snapping at Jimmy and Tosh if she thought her motherhood qualities were ever brought into question.

It was an excellent start to the series, with an intriguing, head-scratching case. We left Jimmy and Tosh searching through the rooms of a hotel (the same hotel owned by the manager who gave Jimmy some lip earlier on in the episode), after they had seen a short video in Daniel’s email inbox from her his sister, who gravely pleaded for him to ‘give them what they wanted or she would die’. Suddenly, Jimmy was faced with a people trafficking racket, or something that looked very much like a people trafficking racket, on the island.

With Duncan now staying with Jimmy (after he was his marriage crumbled) and the promise of something with a returning female friend to the island, it’s safe to say that our likeable copper is going to be kept very busy in this series.

Paul Hirons


13 Comments Add yours

  1. COOKE says:

    I was wrestling with how to express my feelings about the return of Shetland, but your first paragraph does it in a nutshell!
    All the main characters fit, and interact so well, it’s a pleasure to watch, despite the grisly plot.
    As the ‘female friend’ is married to a character played by Derek Riddell, I guess that part of the situation will broaden out as we go along.
    Great stuff!

    Liked by 2 people

  2. Peter Smith says:

    Note that your weekly schedule had Shetland as showing on Wednesday.


  3. Richard Walker says:

    Good review as always and agreed about Shetland being the best of the bunch. Sorry to be pendant but I thought the cocaine traces were in the bag with the severed head not his haversack.


  4. Leonard Rossi says:

    Superb crime thriller actors very rezl life especially douglas hempshall

    Liked by 1 person

  5. R D says:

    Yes traces of cocaine in the vag containing Daniel s severed head,not in HIS hold-all – big difference


  6. Ivy says:

    Can’t wait to read your review of the Batiste.


  7. marblex says:

    I love this show and find it to be of consistently exceptional quality. Your review pretty much says it all.

    Liked by 1 person

  8. Neil Milne says:

    I’m sorry folks but I absolutely disagree with what is being said about this series if Shetland. It’s sloppily written nd smacks of being a cash in on its previous success. I’m very disappointed. The plot holes are massive and the characters are cliched. In terms of a police procedural, it’s woeful. Tosh says let’s get a warrant like they’re something you lift off the shelf but is advised that they don’t have sufficient grounds. Any detective worth their salt wouldn’t even make such a stupid comment. There are many many more such instances. It’s embarrassing. Whoever their advisor is on police matters isn’t being listened to. I get it. There has to be artistic licence to move the plots on but this is nonsense. As usual the accents really wrong. Many will recognise the correct islands accents but the bbc has only got so many of them I guess, so we’re lwft with standard Glaswegians not even attempting to modify their accents. This really is poor stuff. As for the search of the hotel. Don’t get me started. I could go on and on. For the first time, I’m switching it off.


  9. Jen says:

    Where can we watch season 5 in U.S?


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.