SERIES REVIEW Holding (S1)

The Graha Norton novel comes to ITV.

I have to admit, I’m not a huge fan of cosy crime. I understand the appeal and can fully appreciate the umbrella of crime drama shelters a broad range of different types of crime drama, all with their things to say and depict.

But I had low-ish expectations of this ITV four-parter, adapted from the novel by Graham Norton.

Norton, a beloved comic and chatshow host, recently took to writing crime novels, but again this element left me a bit wary – never trust a celebrity who takes to writing novels. Sounds harsh, but it’s always a truism that celebs don’t often make for the best novelists.

However, I’m here to tell you that Holding – despite my reservations – was actually pretty good and an enjoyable, sensitively-handled watch.

It’s set in the sleepy, West Cork village of Duneen, fringed as it is by beautiful, lush countryside and invitingly deserted coves and beaches. So far, so cosy.

Duneen itself is populated by a ragtag of quirky characters – the grumpy housekeeper Mrs Meeney, the gossipy Mrs O’Driscoll and the trio of Ross sisters on the farm. And then there’s PJ Collins (Conleth Hill), a pudgy, timid gardaí who has a compulsion of shovelling crisps and white bread into his mouth when he’s stressed.

Thankfully for him, Duneen doesn’t provide too much stress. It’s bustling but is a small town and everything is as it should be – quiet, peaceful and days that melt into the next.

However, when human remains are discovered during building on a local farm things change. That’s when both the town’s and PJ’s slumber are rudely interrupted. With some Cork, city-based detectives sent in to assist PJ – who’s clearly terrified of this development and out of his depth – it’s quickly determined that the body could well be that of Tommy Burke, who disappeared from the area 20 years ago.

From the moment Burke’s name is mentioned, it stirs up a whole heap of buried memories for two women in particular – Bríd Riorden (Siobhán McSweeney), who Burke left at the alter, and his lover, Evelyn Ross (Charlene McKenna).

As the plot, which gets a bit convoluted as the episodes tick by, develops there’s the ‘small town, big secrets’ trope, something that we’ve seen time and time again in many crime dramas.

But what makes Holding work so well is not the depth of the plot, it’s the genuinely fine performances from the ensemble cast, and a willingness to revel in the richness of character. And that’s down to good writing (yes you, Graham Norton). The real boon of Holding is that it never feels like a pastiche or a Father Ted-style lampooning of Irish small-town communities.

While the humour is there it’s never in your face, more gentle quirkiness rather than ‘to be sure’ caricatures. All the characters have lived lives, have made mistakes and have fallen in love when they shouldn’t have. And now they’re having to deal with the consequences of their actions.

There’s a lot to like here, mostly in the richness of characterisation and depth of performance. Every time I see Charlene McKenna she gets better and better (Peaky Blinders, Bloodlands etc), and here she’s full of spirit, recklessness but also vulnerability. Siobhan McSweeney, too, is excellent as is Brenda Fricker, who delivers an acting masterclass when she reveals her own devastating secret.

And there’s Conleth Hill, who as the main character PJ is loveable and someone you almost write off – he’s content to be in the background but is waging his own private war against his own demons. It’s a skilful performance from Hill.

Holding is not perfect by any means. Some characters feel superfluous and do not work at all (see DI Linus Dunne), and it does jump around a little bit. But overall Holding is a quirky, enjoyable cosy crime drama populated by characters you’d quite like to see again.

After series one’s success, I wouldn’t bet against ITV taking another trip to Duneen in the near future.

Paul Hirons

Rating: 3.5 out of 5.

Holding is now available to stream in the UK on ITV Hub

4 Comments Add yours

  1. marijo1951 says:

    I read both Graham Norton’s novels and was surprised at how good they were. Then I read an interview in which Norton said that the reaction of most people to his novels seemed to be surprise at how good they were!

    Like

  2. Halebank Pat says:

    I loved it and I’m hoping for a new series

    Like

  3. Elaine says:

    Great review thank you. I enjoyed it overall and thought the characters were fully formed and interesting and in general well acted. And then you had Brenda Fricker who lifted the whole series with her superlative acting in episode 3. PJ was likeable and I hope we spend more time with him. A couple of slight negatives (might be too harsh a word) were I guessed the murderer in episode 2, and thought the ‘mystery’ around the bones was quite obvious and I guessed that too. But overall a good watch.

    Like

  4. Sorry but Conleth Hill was too much like his early impersonation of Benny Hill to take seriously. I think it was a bit like Father Ted but not funny and Pauline McGlynn doing her Mrs Doyle didn’t help. There was some good acting and Siobhan Mc Sweeney was so consistently good but others were struggling to rise out of this risible dramatisation of what was a good tale.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.