REVIEW Shetland (S7 E6/6)

After nine years and 38 episodes, this was the moment Douglas Henshall bid farewell to Jimmy Perez, the Shetland islands’ very own chief protector and high sheriff.

Like all the best crime characters, Henshall and Perez seemed a perfect match – Henshall’s friendly, soft features belying a simmering passion and old-fashioned masculinity beneath the surface. They fitted each other like a glove, and although he’s enjoyed success elsewhere, Jimmy Perez felt like Henshall’s ultimate role.

All that being said, we had a complex case to tie up, and, of course, had to find out how Perez was going to leave the show. Would it be with Meg, after realising that the job finally had become too much for him and a hindrance to future happiness; or would it be on a stretcher on the way to the morgue?

This has been a strong series, with an engrossing story at its heart – aptly, with Shetland and the islands’ future and wellbeing at its heart.

But there was plenty of drama before we found out what was to be Jimmy’s fate. Jamie Nary (possibly the only lead who wasn’t processed or had much of a backstory so far) was revealed to be the eco-terrorist and murderer at large around Lerwick, and there proceeded a frantic evacuation of the town centre and search for the wanted man. We all know that Shetland has, in the past, used up its budget with some pyrotechnics and explosions, so blowing up Lerwick was not out of the realm of possibility. And, of course, we had the Jimmy question always at the back of our minds – any dicey situation provoked an ‘OH GOD THIS IS IT’ reaction.

So when Jimmy – trademark pea coat with its collars turned up, naturally – waded through the streets of the town, quite obviously in extreme jeopardy, we all no doubt wondered whether this was going to be it for him. And when he had a one-on-one confrontation with Nary (who explained he was avenging his ex-activist partner’s death) on a cliff edge, the latter clutching his bomb, our anxiety deepened.

Thankfully, Jimmy survived.

However, breathing a sigh of relief was one thing, but when it came to the story and the case, I really didn’t buy Jamie Nary’s motivation for murdering Connor and Bryd. At all. He said they weren’t committed enough. Was that enough to kill two people? It felt a little lame to me.

However, with Nary on his hospital bed, he admitted to the murders of Connor and Bryd, but not to Suitcase Man. So another murderer was out there. With Lloyd Anderson still in the cells, and no one else knowing about his double life, the only person who could’ve done anything to anyone threatening his existence was his wife, Alison, another person who hasn’t yet been properly examined as a suspect. And so Alison it was.

It was an interesting reveal, full of emotion – as we all thought, Jimmy found a way to let Lloyd go and recommend a safe and sudden route out of the country, but he had to leave behind the woman he loved and the woman who, in many ways, sacrificed her own future to save his.

This complex and nuanced situation was Shetland all over – full of grey areas and flawed characters – and certainly, the final scenes ramped up the emotion. Jimmy told a furious Rhona – who had just found out about Lloyd Anderson’s release – that he was quitting and he then had to tell Tosh. Wow, what an emotional scene – the master passing on his torch to the apprentice, an apprentice who admitted her nervousness and pondered on whether she could do the job. I was close to tears at this parting of the ways.

I think I speak for all fans of the show when I say that she is well up to the job, and we’ll be cheering her on. She brings with her more of an emotional approach to policing, to go along with her outstanding instincts. Series eight has been commissioned, don’t forget, and will start production soon. I hope they don’t muck things around. I want to see Tosh as a DI.

As for Jimmy, he did indeed choose Meg and happiness over his career; a career that he had used to create distance between himself and any emotional attachment since the death of Fran, his first wife. He wanted to be happy again, and he took the plunge. Finally.

When a beloved character says farewell, you just want them to be happy. Realising that he was putting himself in danger more often than she should be, and flying closer to the flame more than he had ever done, he actually made the right decision.

To live and to be happy.

Although the landing to the case was a little bumpy, you can’t argue with the nature of and the motivations for Jimmy’s farewell.

To quote a famous film, he chose life.

Paul Hirons

Episode rating

Rating: 4 out of 5.

Series rating

Rating: 4 out of 5.






Shetland is broadcast on BBC One and iPlayer in the UK


6 Comments Add yours

  1. Michael Sargent says:

    Who was Jamie Nary – all these bearded men look the same – whilst watching I thought he was maybe the librarian but clearly that wasn’t the case! I don’t remember him from earlier episodes! Help!
    Apart from not recognising him I enjoyed it especially the touching end.


    1. Elaine says:

      Hi Michael, he was Connor’s book publisher.


  2. Elaine says:

    Thank you once again for your great review. I have enjoyed this series of Shetland more than the previous one, although I don’t think it’s been the strongest. The murders at the heart of it were interesting enough, and was well paced, perhaps until the end when suddenly they were all solved in a couple of hours. From the previous episode I wondered if Jimmy was going to let Lloyd go, but did for a second think they were actually going to have Lloyd guilty and Jimmy realising he can’t do this anymore. But instead they went down the predictable route, which was nice enough and Jimmy got his happy ending. Lovely farewells and a reasonably satisfying ending. Certainly a lot better than many series this year, a solid 7 1/2.


  3. Michael Sargent says:

    And who set the caravan up to explode and why? Not pacifist Connor presumably… did he reveal to Jamie where it was in which case why did he booby trap it?


  4. John Dutton says:

    Like others had difficulty placing Jamie but really glad producer didn’t kill Jimmy off in the end. Cannot see him settling down to domestic bliss though! Or opening a coffee shop!!!


  5. Brian D. says:

    Lloyd’s wife murdered the American “Suitcase Man.” She stuffed him in a suitcase. This may be a minor point–I wondered why she hacked off his finger tips? I don’t think she had the presence of mind to think about fingerprints. Too gruesome; a bit out-of-place. Also; We were never told how Tosh escaped–AND–got far enough away from the violent explosion. This frantic; seconds-from-death experience took place; with about two–or three–seconds left on the bomb timer. Just curious. All in all; an excellent series, and a fitting; believable exit/tribute for DI Perez. I like Sandy; but I suppose Tosh willl get the nod. Not sure how the series will fare….It will be empty w/o Jimmy Perez.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.